We get asked this question most weeks. Someone has a tired, worn staircase, and they are not sure whether to have it clad over or whether they should just bite the bullet and have a whole new flight put in. Both are valid routes and we do both, but they suit very different situations, and it is worth understanding the difference before you commit any money.
The short version is that cladding works brilliantly when the structure underneath is sound and the layout is not changing, and a new staircase is the right call when the structure is genuinely worn out, the layout needs to change, or you want a different style of stair entirely, such as an open riser design where a closed one exists now.
What staircase cladding actually involves
Cladding, sometimes called re-treading or re-skinning, means fitting new treads, risers, stringers and often a new handrail and spindles over or alongside the existing structure. The old staircase stays in place underneath doing the structural work it has always done, and what changes is everything you see and touch. It is a bit like re-facing kitchen units rather than ripping the carcasses out.
This suits stairs where the timber structure is solid, there is no bounce or movement, and the only real complaint is that it looks dated, the carpet has gone, or the treads are chipped and worn. We can usually change spindle style completely, swap a boxed string for an open one on the visible face, and bring in oak or engineered treads over an old softwood stair, all without touching the frame that holds it up.
It is also considerably less disruptive. A cladding job typically takes a few days rather than the best part of two weeks, and you can usually still use the stairs, carefully, on the evenings when we are not actively working on them.
When a new staircase is the only sensible option
If the staircase creaks, flexes underfoot, or has had botched repairs over the years, cladding it is just putting a nice coat on a problem that is still there. We would rather tell you honestly that it needs replacing than sell you a cosmetic fix that will not last.
A new staircase is also the answer if you want to change the pitch, widen it, move the position of the winders, or open it up where it currently feels boxed in and dark. Those are structural and layout changes that cladding cannot deliver, because cladding by definition works with the existing geometry rather than altering it.
Building regulations in general terms
Staircases sit under Part K and Part M of the Building Regulations, which cover things like going and rise, headroom, handrail height and gaps between spindles. If you are cladding an existing staircase and keeping the same geometry, you are usually working within a stair that was already compliant, or at least already there, so the regulatory bar is lower.
Replace the staircase, or change the spindle spacing, handrail height or pitch, and building control involvement becomes far more likely, particularly if the property is a house with more than one storey above ground level. We always flag this early rather than partway through a job, because it affects both timescale and cost, and it is far better to know from day one.
Cost and disruption side by side
As a broad guide for the south of England, cladding an average domestic staircase tends to sit somewhere in the low to mid thousands depending on finish and spindle style, while a full new staircase, particularly one that involves structural changes or building control sign off, typically runs from the mid thousands upward. These are guide ranges only, and every staircase we quote gets measured and looked at in person before we put a figure on it.
Disruption follows a similar pattern. Cladding can often be done with the household still living around it, whereas a full replacement usually means the stairs are out of use for a period, which matters a great deal if you have only one staircase serving the whole house.
- Cladding: faster, less disruptive, lower cost, works only with a sound existing structure
- New staircase: needed for structural issues, layout changes or a different pitch
- Building regulations apply more heavily to replacements than to like for like cladding
- Both routes can use the same range of finishes, from painted spindles to oak treads
Matching the staircase to the rest of the house
Whichever route you take, the staircase tends to be one of the first things anyone sees on entering the house, so it is worth thinking about how it ties in with hallway panelling or skirting you already have or are planning. We often clad a staircase at the same time as fitting wall panelling in the hallway, so the two are designed together rather than as separate jobs that happen to sit next to each other.
This is also the point to decide on finish. Painted spindles with an oak handrail is a popular middle ground, giving a crisp look without the full cost of an all timber stair, and it works whether you are cladding or replacing.
How we approach a first visit
When we come to look at a staircase, we spend time underneath it as well as on it, checking for movement, checking the stringers are sound, and looking at how it was originally built. That tells us honestly whether cladding is viable or whether we would be recommending a replacement.
We would rather have that conversation up front than start a cladding job and discover halfway through that the structure cannot be trusted. It has never once felt like wasted time to the homeowners we have said this to.
Getting a proper look and a quote
If your staircase needs attention, give us a ring on 02380 201687 or 07833 227576, or drop an email to info@vipwalls.co.uk, and we will come and have a proper look before recommending anything. We would rather spend twenty minutes on your stairs and give you the right answer than guess over the phone.
Common questions
- Can any staircase be clad?
- Not quite any, but most staircases where the structure is sound can be clad successfully. We check for movement, creaking and stringer condition before recommending it, and if the structure is not up to it we will say so.
- Does cladding a staircase need building control approval?
- Usually not if you are keeping the same geometry, but it depends on your existing stair and any changes to spindle spacing or handrail height. We will tell you honestly if we think your job needs sign off.
- How long does staircase cladding take compared to a new stair?
- Cladding typically takes a few days, while a full replacement can take one to two weeks depending on structural work and whether building control needs to inspect at various stages.
- Will cladding hide creaks?
- It can quieten some noises but it will not fix a genuinely loose or moving structure. If your stairs creak because of movement rather than a loose tread, that needs addressing at the structural level, which may mean a new staircase.
- Can I change the spindle style without a new staircase?
- Yes, this is one of the most common reasons people choose cladding. We can fit a completely different spindle and handrail style over an existing sound structure without touching the frame underneath.
Read next